George is dating Patrice, an accountant and former IRS agent, who wears a cheongsam and hair sticks on a date, aspires to make papier-mâché hats as a career, and quotes Thomas Carlyle. Weary of her behavior, George tries to break up without blaming her. Patrice demands the truth from George, and, in an outburst, he accuses her of pretentiousness. George takes Patrice's calm and collected reaction at face value.
However, Jerry had been relying on George to secure Patrice's help to extricate him from a tax audit, caused by taking deductions for donating to a relief fund for a bogus Krakatoa eruption. Jerry blames Kramer for interrupting his first date with Elaine to fundraise, and Elaine mocks Jerry for trying to impress her by donating $50. Having forgotten all this, George lets Patrice leave with Jerry's tax records in hand.
George's faith in his own brutal honesty proves unfounded, as Patrice fails to return to work, and checks herself into a depression clinic, to Jerry's dismay. At the clinic, George grudgingly reconciles with Patrice for Jerry's sake, but Patrice has already thrown out Jerry's papers. Having failed to make copies, Jerry is reduced to revisiting stores one by one to reassemble old receipts, while George continues to suffer through Patrice's artistic whims.
Kramer, dating Elaine's roommate Tina, creates many unwelcome impositions at Elaine's apartment, including leaving the kitchen in disarray, playing loud tribal dance music while rambunctiously making out on the couch, and walking in on Elaine without warning while she is naked. He also finds a discarded windshield and turns it into a coffee table, despite being warned that the glass is invisible. Noticing Elaine's exasperation, Kramer and Tina ask her for the truth, but she does not repeat George's mistake and answers diplomatically. Excited by Elaine's approval, Tina and Kramer roll into the coffee table with the lights out, smashing it and severely injuring themselves.